At Fat Cat Coffee Works, Community Is Always on the Menu

What began as a modest family coffee shop in a former mill has become a welcoming gathering place near the Sugar River State Trail. For Ally Sayre and her family, the greatest rewards have little to do with what goes into a coffee cup.

At Fat Cat Coffee Works, Community Is Always on the Menu
Ally Sayre, general manager of Fat Cat Coffee Works, holds her son behind the counter of the family-owned New Glarus cafe. Sayre grew up helping her parents, Anne and John Miller, build the business and now carries on their tradition of good food, hospitality and community involvement. – Photo by Emma Hendrickson

At Fat Cat Coffee Works, the aroma of fresh coffee and something baking in the oven is only part of the attraction. For nearly two decades, the New Glarus business has been a place to meet an old friend, catch up with a neighbor, linger over breakfast or simply feel at home.

Its story is also one of a family finding its place in the community. Anne and John Miller opened Fat Cat in 2007, beginning with a small rented portion of an old mill building at 606 Railroad St. John handled the coffee and espresso, while Anne baked muffins and cookies. There was no full-service kitchen, no large staff and none of the expansive menu customers know today.

Over time, the Millers purchased the building, knocked down a wall, installed a commercial kitchen and expanded into the entire space. Today, the cafe serves breakfast and lunch, bakes its own pastries and desserts, and employs as many as 15 people during the busy summer season. The historic building, close to the Sugar River State Trail, has become part of its identity.

For general manager Ally Sayre, the business is especially personal. She grew up in New Glarus, graduated from New Glarus High School in 2009 and was a teenager when her mother and stepfather opened the shop. What began as helping the family business eventually became her calling.

Remaining content is for paid members only.

Please subscribe to any paid plan to unlock this article and more content.

Already have an account? Sign in

Comments available to premium members.

Create a premium account and join the discussion.

Already have an account? Sign in

Sign up for our New Glarus 360 newsletters

Breaking news, things to do and alumni updates—delivered.

Please check your inbox and confirm. Something went wrong. Please try again.