Puempel’s Olde Tavern in New Glarus Is For Sale

One of New Glarus’ most beloved institutions is on the market. With roots dating to 1893, Puempel’s Olde Tavern has been a downtown gathering place for generations, and its listing raises questions about the future of the historic establishment.

Puempel’s Olde Tavern in New Glarus Is For Sale
The historic exterior of Puempel’s Olde Tavern in downtown New Glarus, a landmark whose character and traditions have been carefully preserved for decades. Longtime owner Chuck Bigler purchased the establishment in 1992, continuing its legacy as one of the village’s most recognizable businesses. – Photos by Justin Lackner Photography

– Photos by Justin Lackner Photography

One of New Glarus’ oldest and most recognizable businesses, Puempel’s Olde Tavern, is on the market, marking a potentially significant turning point for a downtown institution whose history stretches back more than 130 years.

The historic tavern on Sixth Avenue has been a gathering place for generations of New Glarus residents and visitors, known for its old-fashioned atmosphere, original furnishings, historic murals and deep connections to the community’s Swiss heritage. The property is being marketed through EXIT Realty and is listed for a price of $850,000.

The $850,000 asking price includes considerably more than Puempel's Tavern itself. According to the listing agent, the sale includes both the historic tavern at 18 Sixth Ave. and the adjoining commercial space occupied by Lollygag Antiques at 16 Sixth Ave. Unlike a real estate-only transaction, the offering also includes the operating Puempel's Tavern business. Above the two downtown commercial spaces are three apartments and a private laundry room.

The sale also includes a separate residential property at 517 Railroad St. behind the building, along with a storage garage identified in the real estate listing. Together, the properties represent a combination of commercial, residential and business assets being offered as a single $850,000 package. The listing agent confirmed that the property's tax bill uses the 16 Sixth Ave. address, even though Puempel's operates at 18 Sixth Ave.

Remaining content is for paid members only.

Please subscribe to any paid plan to unlock this article and more content.

Already have an account? Sign in

Comments available to premium members.

Create a premium account and join the discussion.

Already have an account? Sign in

Sign up for our New Glarus 360 newsletters

Breaking news, things to do and alumni updates—delivered.

Please check your inbox and confirm. Something went wrong. Please try again.