The New Glarus Family Behind a Landmark Adoption Battle

A young widow refused to surrender the little boy she had raised as her son. With help from her New Glarus family, she took on Wisconsin’s welfare department in a fight that would reach the state’s highest court and reveal a flaw in the law.

The New Glarus Family Behind a Landmark Adoption Battle
Dorothy Tschudy became the center of a landmark Wisconsin adoption case in the 1950s after a bitter custody battle reached the state Supreme Court. Her fight would have lasting consequences for Wisconsin adoption law. This digital rendering is based on a historical newspaper photograph preserved by Newspapers.com.

The little boy had already been given their name. Jeffrey Vernon Tschudy had been baptized in an Albany church, and Dorothy and Vernon Tschudy were preparing to make him legally their son. Then, on the way home from a Florida vacation in April 1953, Vernon died suddenly in Alabama.

For Dorothy, a 29-year-old widow with a toddler to raise, the loss was devastating enough. But Wisconsin’s welfare authorities soon confronted her with another: Without a husband, they would no longer approve her plan to adopt Jeffrey.

Dorothy refused to accept that decision. She moved with the boy back home to New Glarus, resisted orders to give him up and turned to the courts. Her family offered its farm as financial security. The struggle became a public controversy and eventually reached the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

It would end with a ruling against Dorothy. Yet her fight would leave a mark on Wisconsin law far beyond the courtroom in Green County.

Remaining content is for paid members only.

Please subscribe to any paid plan to unlock this article and more content.

Already have an account? Sign in

Comments available to premium members.

Create a premium account and join the discussion.

Already have an account? Sign in

Sign up for our New Glarus 360 newsletters

Breaking news, things to do and alumni updates—delivered.

Please check your inbox and confirm. Something went wrong. Please try again.